Dear Theo,
Hi! It’s Daddy! You know, Daddy, the guy chasing you around the house every night trying to get you to brush your teeth, and the guy who is supposed to somehow remember the exact location of 343 toy cars in our house because at any random moment you’re going to ask me to get one for you.
It’s time for my annual letter to you on your birthday. Saturday is Halloween and also, of course, the day you turn 3! Yep, you’ve made it to the Big 3, and boy oh boy, there were lots of times in the past 12 months when I wasn’t sure any of us would live to see this day.
I have so many things I want to tell you today, Theo, about the incredible changes we’ve seen in you since you last blew out candles. Many of those changes have been good. Many of those changes have been … less good.
Bad, even.
I joked to Mommy the other night that one letter wouldn’t be enough to sum up your year; I’d need a four-volume set of letters.
But before we get to all that’s happened in your life, let me first remind you that Mommy and I love you so much, and that you have brought indescribable joy into our family these last three years.
Your laugh, your smile, your silliness, your love of so many things, lights up our world and makes us so happy that out of all the millions of men in the universe, I’m the one you call Daddy.
Theo, this last year has been a challenging one for the world, and of course for you. The scourge of Covid-19 has meant we couldn’t go play with friends, or to the playground for a while, and a lot of the classes you enjoyed so much were stopped.
I can’t say for sure if this led to an immediate downturn in your behavior, but it sure didn’t help.
Overall, though, you handled the coronavirus stuff pretty well for a 2-year-old, and you’ve even started wearing your mask at preschool, a move I thought we’d never get you to make.
There are so many elements of your personality that have come out this year, Theo, to show us just how very different you are from Nate.
You are way more adventurous than he is, from climbing on the playground, to trying new foods (you love sausage and hot dogs, something that horrifies me and Grandma Sandy) to having new experiences.
You entertain us so much, Theo, with your sayings. They’ve ranged from your several-week period this summer where Mommy or I would say something and you’d exclaim “That’s a GREAT idea, Daddy!”, to when you ask for something like grapes and then say “I want ALL the grapes!”
You have so much love for teasing and playing with your brother; one of your favorite things to do is take one of Nate’s toys, walk to him with it behind your back, grinning, and say “Nate, I’ve got a surprise for you!” and then thrusting the toy in his face.
Your love of music has exploded this year, from the “Sing” soundtrack which I’ve now committed to permanent memory, to your two hilariously old-school new favorite songs, “Who Let the Dogs Out” by the Baha Men, and “Tubthumping” by Chumbawamba (that’s the “I get knocked down, but I get up again” song).
Your personality has gone through wild swings this year, Theo, but that’s normal for a 2-year-old.
Some nights you’re in the best mood ever, as you love asking me and Nate to lie down and make a human sandwich, so you can scream “I want to be the meat!” and get in the middle. Every single time, you giggle with glee as I shake you and Nate up and down in our sandwich.
Other nights, you’re impossible, and even the smallest requests like having you get out of the bath, can lead to screaming that could wake the dead.
Some other big changes this year, Theo, have been you becoming potty-trained! We are so proud of how well you’ve taken to it since we started in May; some small regressions lately aside, you’ve really become a champ at rushing over to your potty and doing your business. You’ve even started going to the big-boy bathrooms on your own, surprising the hell out of us when you do it.
You also started preschool in September, which thrilled us all to no end, because we felt your behavior would improve with socialization.
Still waiting on that behavior improvement, but man do you love school. Mommy and I were elated when you got sad after your first full week of school when we informed you there was no school today, it was Saturday.
Your face dropped, as if to say “whaddaya mean, no school? I go every day!”
You’ve had so much fun getting to know other kids, listening to your teachers, and picking up new skills, like sitting criss-cross applesauce, and painting.
So, much of the time, Theo, you’ve been a delight. But I want to be totally honest in these letters, so I can accurately portray exactly what your life was like at the time I wrote.
So in that spirit, I want to tell you this: You have been a very, very difficult toddler. You throw constant tantrums, your listening skills border on non-existent, and no matter how many times Mommy and I (and Nate, who sort of thinks of himself as your third parent) tell you something, you never, ever remember it for next time.
You’ve gone through so many disastrous phases of acting out, Theo, from throwing food all over the place, to destroying toys (yours and Nate’s), to being violent and aggressive with your brother, to smacking Mommy and me … it’s been really, really hard. Trying to get you to sleep was awful for a few months, as you screamed and cried for this or that.
Then there was the phase where you wouldn’t get IN the car. Then for a while we couldn’t get you OUT of the car. We keep thinking eventually you’re going to get it, that months and months of us telling you the rules, correcting your behavior, or trying any of the methods we’ve tried to modify it (ignore the behavior, be calm about it, scream about it) have failed.
In the last month, Theo, thanks partially to school, things have gotten a little better.
But man, there have been more than a few times when, during one of your classic tantrums, Nate has looked at me and said “Daddy, you’re right. We should just sell him.” (I tell him it’s a buyer’s market for cute kids right now, we’ll wait a little bit.)
But we know this is all a part of the process; we were just spoiled by Nate’s angel-like behavior at this age. Theo, you are your own wonderful, free spirit, and I can’t wait to see what this year will bring.
Your hugs are still the best thing ever, and your beaming face when I come to pick you up from preschool every day is so special to see.
We love you to infinity and beyond, Theo, and hope you have the best birthday ever.
Love always,
Daddy
P.S. One day soon you’ll be able to hug your grandparents again. I promise.